Viola Talk Forum | Violaman.com

Topic RSS

Question for Violists and Cellists - Forced Shifting

Question about sheet music with a shift inserted for the sake of adding a shift.

Topic Rating: 0 (0 votes)

Mouse

March 2, 2023 - 12:38 pm

Member Since: July 8, 2021

Forum Posts: 490

Offline

I am working on a piece that the lesson book seems to have added a forces shift, for the sake of shifting, on a cello song. It is just plain awkward. It does not belong there. I have done shifting. I was thinking I should just do it the way it does not feel forced so that I can concentrate on the bowing and use other pieces, where shifting is necessary, to re-enforce shifting.

It is holding me back because it is just awkward. I am not hesitant to do shifting, I like shifting down the cello, or up the viola, but it does not belong here. I am not taking lessons, I am learning on my own, but started shifting while taking lessons.

If any of you guests have any thoughts on this, please join in and reply with your thoughts. What would you do?

The Bumble Bee Flies

Please ignore any typos. My typing ability on a real typewriter did not transfer to these device key pads.

wtw

Regular Member

Members

Regulars

March 4, 2023 - 5:25 am

Member Since: January 13, 2019

Forum Posts: 96

Offline

I wouldn't force it if you don't see the point - if it doesn't help with the fingerings in that passage, or to avoid an open string, or something.

In an exercise dedicated to shifting, it would be normal, but not in a piece/tune…

Is it the first time it happens in this book : other shifts/fingerings usually make sense?

Mouse

March 5, 2023 - 8:37 am

Member Since: July 8, 2021

Forum Posts: 490

Offline

Thanks. It really isn't a necessary shift. I have done songs that I don't know and will automatically put a shift in because it just seems right and feels right, ie avoid open string that needs to be played on a fingered string. This just not feel that way.

I kept at it because I don't like to dodge trouble spots, I like to work them through because then I will know what to do in the future. I was not sure if that was the case here. It never feels right and I did not even do the shift until I noticed the marking. So, I think I will skip it.

They have added odd things in other songs, occasionally, not often. I am going to do it the way it feels right to me. I am playing for my own benefit and by myself anyway.

Thanks, wtw. Your questions about it helped me think it through.

Any guests with any thoughts on this, please join in on the conversation. Help us help others. Thank you.

The Bumble Bee Flies

Please ignore any typos. My typing ability on a real typewriter did not transfer to these device key pads.