Log In
Register
Home
Topic RSS
(0 votes) 
Regulars
Offline
I'm thinking of getting Fischer's Basics book. If you know it, what do you think of it and how useful would you rate it? It looks complete enough.
The fact that it's written for violin, with exercises in treble clef and not alto clef, should not be a great inconvenience.
I've got Paul Rolland's Teaching of action in string playing, and I like it a lot. It focuses on balance and natural motions. But it doesn't cover everything (was looking up trills the other day - didn't find it: of course, there's not much motion involved in a trill).
I've got Galamian's Principles of violin playing and teaching too. But I don't like it as much. It's a smaller book: less details there, and it doesn't stay open by itself, which is a pain. Does Fischer's stay open?
Offline
If you have to get another book, Basics is the book to get. My teacher's remedial work with me is mostly to be found in Basics, although, being Italian, she is unaware of Fischer.
But a book won't observe you nor see nor hear your faults.
Violinists seem to worry a lot about trills, to judge by the number of preparatory exercises I've seen. I don't understand it - they are totally normal on flute, clarinet, oboe. You wiggle a finger up and down quickly, with feeling (joke, or not?)
On the violin one tends to avoid the pinky (unavoidable on wind instruments)
Apart from that, you just have to listen to intonation.
Regulars
Offline
Thanks for the input. I bought Firscher's book, now I only have to do the "work".
Intonation is not really a problem here, but my trills are not consistent. Can sound good, or bad, depends. Also I have trouble with long trills, on more than one bow - with a bow change in the middle, and maybe a change in trill speed. Like here. I want to achieve that but need some more control…
But I may skip trills with the 4th finger.
Your teacher may know of Fischer but just not have used it during her music training?
Offline
But your problem may be your bowing technique, not your trilling technique - some things only a teacher can diagnose.
Regulars
Offline
Well, I won't be getting a teacher anytime soon - hence the book. I'll see how it helps, with other things too. I think my left hand is at fault. And/or the brain-to-hand connection.
Offline
@wtw I have the following, but not sure if they will be helpful. I have a hard time disciplining myself to use them properly, but some have some neat tunes to use to learn.
Manfred Schmitz: A Little Pop Music Viola
Schirmer's Library of Musical Classics: MOGILL Scale Studies for Viola Based on the Hrimaly Scale Studies for the Violin
Belwin Course for Strings Book 1 for Viola:String Builder by Samuel Applebaum
Belwin Course for Strings Book 2 for Viola: First Position Etudes for Strings by Samuel Applebaum
J. Frederick Müller & Harold W. Rusch Viola Book 1: String Method for Class or Individual Study
These are Viola so not in treble clef. I need to get back to this and try to be more disciplined.
I also have some some books for viola.
The Bumble Bee Flies
Learn Viola on Violaman and Fiddlerman's Fiddle Talk
1 Guest(s)
Mouse
